10.10.02Historic Preservation Board
Meeting Notice and Agenda
Date: October 10, 2002
Location: Sanford City Hall
City Commission Chambers
300 North Park Avenue, Sanford, Florida 32771
Time: Workshop 5:00 p.m.
Regular Meeting 7:00 p.m.
Workshop
Workshop with Land Design Innovations to review amendments to Schedule S, Historic
Preservation, of the Sanford Land Development Regulations
Regular Meeting
1. Call to Order
2. Roll Call - excused and unexcused absences
3. Approval of Minutes: Workshop & Regular Meeting, September 12, 2002
Special meeting, September 26, 2002
4. Applications for Certificates of Appropriateness — Commercial District
a) 212 W. I' Street Demolish existing noncontributing building
5. Applications for Certificates of Appropriateness — Residential District
a)
1008 Myrtle Ave.
Construct single family residence (Con't. from 9/12/02)
b)
605 Palmetto Ave.
Install shed in backyard; stucco I' floor of garage
C)
705 Magnolia Ave.
Replace oak porch floor with Pau Lope hardwood floor
d)
615 Park Ave.
Restore front porch to original form
e)
611 Oak Ave.
Construct rear porch
f)
706 Palmetto Ave.
Revise approved window installation
6. Minor
Reviews
7. 6 -month Reviews
a)
1115 S. Myrtle Ave.
Replace window with wood window
b)
413 S. Myrtle Ave.
6' wood stockade fence
C)
101 W. 9 1 '' St.
6' board -on -board fence
d)
408 Palmetto Ave.
Move window on side of house
e)
1021 S. Elm Ave.
Replace siding & windows
f)
1020 S. Elm Ave.
Add deck & railing to front of house
g)
1201 S. Oak Ave.
Remove addition to house
h)
908 Magnolia Ave.
Install shutters
i)
1401 Magnolia Ave.
Cut holes in walls to install a/c units
8. Chairman
and Board's items
for discussion
9. Adjournment.
MINUTES
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
WORKSHOP
OCTOBER 10, 2002
5:00 P.M.
CITY COMMISSION CHAMBERS
CITY HALL, SANFORD, FLORIDA
Mr. Singeisen called the meeting to order at 5:10 P.M.
Mr. Singeisen presented Ms. Pat Tyjeski who presented the board with a draft copy of
the revise schedule S of the Land Development Regulations.
Ms. Tyjeski reviewed the revisions to schedule S with the board.
Board members made recommendations for the addition or deletion of items and
rewording of items thought to be unclear. The inclusion of particular definitions was
requested. Subheadings were requested to further clarify some topics.
The board was not able to review all revisions to schedule S in this workshop session. It
was determined that an additional meeting was needed to complete the review. A special
meeting was scheduled for October 24 at 5:00. Ms. Tyjeski agreed that she would be
able to attend the meeting.
There being no further business, the workshop was adjourned at 7:00 P.M.
1.
MINUTES
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
OCTOBER 10, 2002
7:00 P.M.
CITY COMMISSION CHAMBERS
CITY HALL, SANFORD, FLORIDA
MEMBERS PRESENT
Scott Singeisen
Barbara Farrell
Rey Sylvester
Stephen Myers
Denny Gibbs
Maria Shreve
Marveen Kelly
Mary Valente
Leslie Stevens
MEMBERS ABSENT
Thomas Goodman
Alexander Then
OTHERS PRESENT
Antonia Gerli, Staff Liaison
Jo -Ann Johnson, Recording Secretary
Mr. Singeisen called the meeting to order at 7:11 P.M.
Mr. Singeisen asked for approval of the September 12 and the special meeting on
September 26, 2002 minutes. Ms. Farrell moved to approve. Ms. Shreve seconded.
Motion carried 9 -0.
Commercial District
Item 4a — 212 W. 1 st St., Demolish existing non - contributing structure; Mike Moreno
1456 Rowland St., Bronx, NY requested the board to approve the demolition of the
structure in order for him to obtain bids for either renovation of the existing building or if
that proved to be too costly to go ahead with new construction. Mr. Singeisen asked if
any drawings, site plans or bids for renovation opposed to new construction were
available. Mr. Moreno stated that he did not have any drawings, he was just in the
exploration period, but would be interested in using the property for 1 or several
professional office use type buildings. Mr. Moreno's concern was that retro fitting the
existing building for office use was expensive and may not provide the best use of the
building. Mr. Singeisen informed the application of the various local agencies that might
provide economic relief for restoration of the building. Mr. Moreno thought that even
1.
with assistance the renovations would be costly. Ms. Gibbs stated that she thought that
might interrupt the cityscape of the downtown area should Mr. Moreno not replace the
building and the property remain vacant. It would also remove a building some other
developer may find a way to renovate. Ms. Valente motioned to deny the application. Ms.
Gibbs seconded. Motion carried 9 -0.
Residential District
Item 4a — 1008 Myrtle Ave., John Guilani, Landmark construction;
Ms. Gibbs motioned to remove application from table of September 12, 2002 meeting.
Mr. Sylvester seconded. Motion carried 9 -0. Mr. Guilani presented the board with
drawings for a new single family house. The board reviewed 2 sets of elevations, A & B.
The board approved front elevation B with the porch from front elevation A with the
stucco to be sand finish. The board requested the horizontal lights on the right side
elevation be removed and a full size window in the front bedroom and a diamond
window in the bathroom over the water closet. They requested if the shutters could be
removed. The carport should be detached, moved 10' off the alley, and can be
constructed with steel columns with an aluminum roof. Mr. Myers moved to approve as
amended. Mr. Sylvester seconded. Motion carried 7 -0. (Ms. Farrell and Ms. Shreve
recused.)
Ms. Kelly and Ms. Shreve departed.
Item 5b1— 605 Palmetto Ave., Brian & Loraine Nash; Leslie McGilvray requested the
board approve the shed. The structure was not visible from Palmetto Ave., is behind a 6'
stockade fence. Mr. Sylvester asked if the shed was already in place on the property. Mr.
Singeisen noted the shed was 80 sq. ft. Mr. Singeisen noted that the Nash's are aware of
the change to the property and are in favor for approval. Ms. Farrell motioned to approve.
Ms. Gibbs seconded. Motion carried 7 -0.
Item 5b2 — 605Y2 Palmetto Ave., Brian Nash., Mr. Nash, 601 Palmetto Ave.,
requested the board approve the addition of stucco on the lower half of the 2 story garage.
There is presently more than 1 type of siding on the building, there is some damaged
wood, and the cost of removing all the existing wood and replacing it is somewhat cost
prohibitive. The lap board siding at the top of the house would remain. He would paint
the building to match the colors of the main house. Ms. Valente asked if he had looked
into replacing the damaged siding on the building with hardy board. Mr. Singeisen asked
what type of siding was on the upper half of the garage. Ms. Stevens stated that her
business had the die to cut the clamshell type siding. Mr. Sylvster motioned to approve
with wood siding. Ms. Gibbs seconded. Motion carried 6 -0. (Ms. Stevens recused.)
Item 5c — 705 Magnolia Ave., Gregory Kupp., Mr. Dave DeVaughn, 701 Magnolia
Ave., Mr. DeVaughn informed the board that the porch flooring would be paulope
hardwood, tongue and groove. Ms. Singeisen asked about the finish. Mr. DeVaughn
stated the finish would be a clear finish. Ms. Farrell motioned to approve. Mr. Myers
seconded. Motion carried 7 -0.
2.
Item 5d — 615 Park Ave., Jon & Jaime Meeks., Mr. Meeks indicated the placement of
the front door was moved to the front left. A porch column would have to be added to the
north side of the porch to replace a missing column. The decking would be tongue and
groove. Mr. Sylvester motioned to approve as submitted. Ms. Stevens seconded. Motion
carried 6 -0. (Mr. Myers recused)
Item 5e — 611 Oak Ave., Kenneth & Linda Dittman. The Dittman's were both present
to answer questions from the board regarding the application of the aluminum screen
porch. The porch is behind the house in the rear yard and not visible from Oak Ave. Mr.
Myers questioned how the addition of this structure complies with the S codes. Mr.
Singeisen mentioned that it was restricted to the rear yard and could be easily removed.
Mr. Myers motioned to approved as submitted. Mr. Sylvester seconded. Motioned carried
7 -0.
Item 5f — 706 Palmetto Ave., Alexander Then. Mr. Singeisen to represent Mr. Then.
This application is to approve removal of the window location on the left hand side. Mr.
Myers motioned to approve as submitted. Ms. Stevens seconded. Motion carried 6 -0.
Six Month Reviews
There being no other business, the meeting adjourned at 9:00.
3