06.10.04Date: June 10, 2004
Location: Sanford City Hall
City Commission Chambers
300 North Park Avenue, Sanford, Florida 32771
Time: 5:00 P.M.
1. Call to Order
2. Roll Call
3. Approval of Minutes: May 13, 2004, meeting
4. Applications for Certificates of Appropriateness — Commercial
214 S. Palmetto Ave. Demolish Buildings; Construct 8 townhouses with offices.
Recommendation to Planning and Zoning Commission to
allow offices on ground floor.
211 E. 1 St Street Remove vitrolite siding to restore original brick walls.
Stucco walls if no brick is uncovered.
5. Applications for Certificates of Appropriateness - Residential District
301 W. 7"' Street Demolish building; Construct 16' X 24' storage shed. (Con't.
from 5/13/04)
1105 S. Oak Ave. Install stained glass in front door.
610 S. Palmetto Ave. Open front porch; Remove plywood and windows from rear
porch and reframe and rescreen & add wood siding; Retrim
door; replace screen door with wood door.
823 Park Ave. Replace window with smaller window.
400 S. Palmetto Ave. Replace front doors; Restore pillars to original size; replace
window.
619 S. Palmetto Ave. Demolish exterior stairs, rear porch and balcony; Construct
rear addition; Replace aluminum windows with wood
windows; Remove chimney.
6. Minor Reviews
7. 6 -month Reviews
104 S. Park Avenue
118 S. Park Avenue
911 Oak Avenue
1015 S. Elm Avenue
708 S. Palmetto Avenue
1118 S. Palmetto Avenue
706 S. Palmetto Avenue
8. Chairman and Board's it
Historic Preservation Board
Meeting Notice and Agenda
Replace aluminum windows; Add canvas valence to awning
Add outdoor light, wrought iron railing and sign
Replace porch columns; Install porch railing and fret work
Add railing to both sides of front porch
Add metal siding around crawl space
Replace windows
Install rear deck; Install metal awning over rear door
ems for discussion
9. Adjournment.
MINUTES
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
MEETING
JUNE 10, 2004
5:00 PM
CITY COMMISSION CHAMBERS
CITY HALL, SANFORD, FLORIDA
Members Present
Denny Gibbs
Alex Then
Stephanie Powers
Steve Myers
Maria Shreve
Leslie Stevens
Barbara Farrell
Staff Present
Andrew VanGaale — Deputy City Manager
Antonia Gerli — Senior Planner
Jo -Ann Johnson - Secretary
Mr. VanGaale addressed the board regarding the Code Enforcement Department's goals and objectives.
He spoke regarding case statistics and asked for any comments from the Historic Preservation Board.
Item 1 — Call to Order - the meeting was called to order at 5:28 p.m.
Item 2 — Roll Call
Item 3 — Approval of Minutes — Mr. Then made a motion to approve the minutes. Ms. Gibbs seconded.
Motion carried 7 -0.
Item 4 — Applications for Certificates of Appropriateness — Commercial District
Item 4A — 214 S. Palmetto Ave., John Giuliani, owner, is requesting approval for demolition of existing
buildings and approval in concept of 8 townhouses with offices.
Ms. Gibbs made the motion to approve in concept, to allow the demolition period be shortened to 60
days, to allow the demolition permit to be issued prior to the building permit being issued, to permit the
lower level to have office and retail use with a sunset clause in 5 years before for new leases are allowed
for office use on ground floor. Ms. Shreve seconded the motion. Motion carried 6 -0 (Farrell recused).
Item 4B — 211 E. 1st St., Robin Marks is requesting approval for removal of vitrolite siding to restore
original brick facade. If no brick exists, stucco will be used.
Ms. Farrell made the motion to approve as presented. Ms Shreve seconded. Motion carried 7 -0.
Item 5 — Applications for Certificates of Appropriateness — Residential District
Item 5A — 301 W. 7 St., Allen Nettles, Building Official for Seminole County School Board is
requesting approval to demolish an accessory building and replace it with a shed.
Historic Preservation Board
June 10, 2004
Page 2
Mr. Nettles stated he had discussed the demolition with the Women's Club of Sanford members and the
school board would need to approve an expenditure of up to $100,000 to replace the existing structure
with a smaller structure to allow the building to be used by school children.
Ms. Gibbs made the motion to continue until the July meeting to get better idea of applicants intent, to get
a correct certificate of appropriateness application that agrees with the intent, and to allow time to provide
elevations of the proposed structure, a site plan as well as a commitment from the Seminole County
School Board that if demolition is granted, the building will be replaced. Mr. Then seconded.
Motion carried 7 -0.
Item 5B — 1105 Oak Ave., - Ms. Kim House, owner, represented by Linda Kuhn, is requesting approval
to install leaded stained glass in the front door.
Ms. Shreve made the motion to approve. Ms. Stevens seconded. Motion carried 7 -0.
Item 5C — 610 Palmetto Ave., Terrie Collins, owner, is requesting approval to open the front porch and
restore to original facade. Remove the plywood and metal window from the rear porch. Frame portion of
porch to match existing wooden siding. Replace metal screen door on porch with wood door and re -trim
door.
Item 5C1 — open front porch, Mr. Then made the motion to approve opening up the front porch. Ms.
Gibbs seconded. Motion carried 7 -0.
Item 5C2 — Remove plywood and metal window from the rear porch. A portion will be sided and balance
will be screened. Mr. Then made the motion to approve as submitted. Ms. Shreve seconded. Motion
carried 7 -0.
Item 5C3 — Mr. Then made the motion to approve as submitted. Ms. Gibbs seconded. Motion carried 7 -0.
Item 5D — 823 Park Ave., Steve Chusmir, postponed until July meeting.
Item 5E — 400 Palmetto Ave., Carla Russell, applicant is requesting approval to replace the front door
with a single wood door with 9 lites (top portion) and sidelights (same size opening). To remove 12"
pillar covers from porches and restore to original 6" x 6 ". Replace bathroom window with same size
window.
Item 5E1 — Ms. Gibbs made the motion to approve door with sidelights on file as submitted. Ms. Farrell
seconded. Motion carried 7 -0.
Item 5E2 - Mr. Then made the motion approve 6" x 6" columns. Ms. Shreve seconded. Motion
carried 7 -0.
Item 5E3 — Mr. Then made the motion to approve. Ms. Shreve seconded. Motion carried 6 -0
(Stevens recused).
Item 5F - 619 Palmetto Ave., Pamela Hendricks, 127 Eastern Fork, Longwood, owner, is requesting
approval to demolish exterior stairs, rear porch and balcony; construct rear addition; replace
aluminum windows with wood windows; and to remove the chimney.
Historic Preservation Board
June 10, 2004
Page 3
Item 5F 1 - Mr. Then made the motion to approve. Ms. Shreve seconded the motion. Motion carried 7 -0.
Item 5F2 — Ms. Gibbs made the motion to approve. Ms. Farrell seconded. Motion carried 7 -0.
Item 5F3 — Ms. Shreve moved to approve as presented, no openings adjusted other than ones indicated on
submittal. Ms. Stevens seconded. Motion carried 7 -0.
Item 5F4 — Ms. Gibbs made the motion to approve. Mr. Then seconded. Motion carried 7 -0.
Item 6 — Minor Reviews
Item 7 — Six Month Reviews
118 S. Park Ave., railing has not been painted.
Item 8 — Board Members Items
Mr. Then — house at 1106 Magnolia Ave., windows on house are not what board approved.
Ms. Powers — Imperial saloon, any progress? Ms. Stevens stated they are waiting for permits to
be issued for window replacement.
Item 9 — There being no further business the meeting adjourned at 8:20 p.m.
F: \SHA ENG \Historic Preservation Board \Minutes \2004 \04 -6 -10 minutes.doc