DO # 22-25_500 Myrtle Avenue_SignedThis Instrument Prepared By and Return To:
Julie Adams Scofield, AICP
Historic Preservation Planner
Planning and Development Services Department
City Hall
300 North Park Avenue
Sanford, Florida 32771
File #: 22-004755
Permit #: COA22-000157
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD OF THE CITY OF SANFORD
DEVELOPMENT ORDER NO. 22-25 RELATING TO 500 MYRTLE AVENUE
APPROVING CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
The Historic Preservation Board (HPB) of the City of Sanford issued this Development
Order relating to an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness under the provisions of
Schedule "S" of the City's Land Development Regulations (LDRs) and controlling Florida law
relating to and touching and concerning the following described property: 500 Myrtle Avenue,
which is assigned Tax Parcel Identification Number: 25-19-30-5AG-0706-0010 by the Seminole
County Property Appraiser.
FINDINGS OF FACT
Property Owner: Oliver and Jessica Bond
500 Myrtle Avenue
Sanford, Florida 32771
Applicant: Oliver Bond
500 Myrtle Avenue
Sanford, Florida 32771
Project: A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to construct a new 16'x 22' garage
relative to property located at, and addressed as, 500 Myrtle Avenue.
Requested Development Approval: The Applicant requested approval to construct a new 16" x
22" garage on property located at 500 Myrtle Avenue. Details were provided in site plans.
Additional Findings: The project is located on a comer lot at 500 Myrtle Avenue in the Sanford
Residential Historic District. The two-story structure was built circa 1912 in a frame vernacular
style. The Applicant requests approval to construct a 16'x 22' garage in the location a garage
previously stood per the 1912-1947 Sanborn Maps, such location presently functions as a patio.
There is an existing curb cut on 5th Street. The Applicant is proposing a product from Tuff Shed
1IPage
r.TA 14 M�AAWAHWW4 M
f!"ANAM 10 . 11 - 1 non A0 11311 A) N ", !('+C i �-' 1, IF'. H
T if 3 1 M .1% On -A I AS SPRIOU J�jf.i
'-(J 01of
MM 'if) 113TANY"
WOR pw:''.•-..+)'`r a SO
100 LKINS
17M
' 2 s.'7" -!I., '-) ; 1..,;: 1.
700 0 hwaymi 01 Wanqu bol"apal WITIQ ON Owntiq1% mah4chiss bumnup'J't
i b:6i anna &OW .100. 11. Any! a VCR .; kal.as alwqcstj no, sumns
Khoo?.Mi A vumvA AINK Q! m; 12 iswan q in bYwA si Mjwj art voggilmleFf InnuMU.
romamw sulro 0 K Q 9 f 'j." a loud 1471 WhINAT01 1:6124, a i
-!may c w�nv'l sh
nd lymp 'K n'si a mnSwi v n"Uwqb onsaw HwQ0qA ody .00?,
c"Munq IS 011
!v; c.,I
bold Ur OVA! ,Ytr,,, 2ii.'oqarj
WWI ARM 4mlymf m 1411 t WAA
to,
'-(J 01of
MM 'if) 113TANY"
WOR pw:''.•-..+)'`r a SO
100 LKINS
17M
' 2 s.'7" -!I., '-) ; 1..,;: 1.
700 0 hwaymi 01 Wanqu bol"apal WITIQ ON Owntiq1% mah4chiss bumnup'J't
i b:6i anna &OW .100. 11. Any! a VCR .; kal.as alwqcstj no, sumns
Khoo?.Mi A vumvA AINK Q! m; 12 iswan q in bYwA si Mjwj art voggilmleFf InnuMU.
romamw sulro 0 K Q 9 f 'j." a loud 1471 WhINAT01 1:6124, a i
-!may c w�nv'l sh
nd lymp 'K n'si a mnSwi v n"Uwqb onsaw HwQ0qA ody .00?,
bold Ur OVA! ,Ytr,,, 2ii.'oqarj
A irmMIQ Vic ism?
to,
using cement lap siding similar to the siding on the house, a gable roof clad with metal matching
the main structure and carriage style doors. The plans submitted include a porch on the south side
of the garage. The north elevation, with garage doors fronting 5th Street, is the only portion of
the garage that will be visible from the street.
Schedule S, Historic Preservation, City of Sanford LDRs states:
Residential Lot Layout
(,-23) Setbacks apply to both principal and accessory structures. Residential lot development
shall have the following setbacks:
• Front yard. Twenty-five feet (25 j;
• Rear Yard. • Two feet (2);
• Side Yard: Five feet (5); When a side yard is located adjacent to a street, the side
yard setback shall be seven and one-halffeet (7.5).
S-23) To protect the pedestrian character of the community and discourage front -loaded
garages, new curb cuts are not allowed within the historic districts for properties that have alley
access.
(S-24) Where alleys are available, new garages shall be detached and located at the rear of the
lot and shall be located no closer than thirty-five feet (35') to the front property line and curb
cuts shall not be allowed.
Schedule S, Historic Preservation (S-39) accessory structures states:
• Prefabricated storage structures shall not exceed one hundred (100) square feet in
area, and are subject to the setback requirements of the district.
• There shall be a minimum separation of ten feet (10') between principal and
accessory structures.
• Accessory structures, such as garages, sheds, etc., shall not exceed the height of the
main structure.
• Accessory structures shall be of similar style, color, design and materials as used for
the principal residence.
The proposed garage does not exceed the height of the main structure. The location is 9 feet
from the primary structure; separations of less than 10 feet has been approved and is acceptable
in this situation since the footprint of a historic structure is proposed for the replacement
structure. The garage has a gable roof with metal to match the primary structure. Windows and
21Page
llfi.lwl! boo W7 W. n .0004 A CV) vKhK W 01 :Mguia phs? I insvis juku
5N; dwop wh no dmuq u uNAW bo :f1; zus!q etc womb iiiufrt of! -j
Io rl"ilhuq �itv) i�-le)(Aj u4j;-w—', flit a xoilnvjlt,, thriDi(
Lum,
inn"Isksk, in, 11511;AAWOR .111m31nt,
,t,7
)!w: mh 1) to lWw"Ju 000A 11 won. ON, i,
oil v1slutg A AN2,
11
'i%AW v(VA
, il ,
- Vf,
lit �,711)
1";:h (-, ?i MIT alunuoe KCal OW )n Wild Al 005y; icy vyl tuman hns)OVVI adl'
insmakol orb K! bue"j"Ol i i ,.;-!!,i;,lj.l,,e Diuwvid a to lubulm'! (ii ei;ll
Ac ?o,AmVll 501 Wool 01 Or- -AT
door are fixed and horizontal sliding windows that though modem and will not be seen from the
street.
(S-29) The following materials are generally acceptable for principal and accessory structures
within the historic districts: 1) Wood clapboard, wood shingle, wood drop siding, wood board
and batten siding or equal as determined by the Board.
The proposed material is cement lap siding in a profile similar to the main structure. The porch
deck is composite, no details are provided
(S-35) New garage doors may be constructed out of wood, steel or fiberglass and shall not
exceed a maximum width of nine (9) feet for a single door on front loaded garages and sixteen
(16) feet on alley -facing garages -
(S -35) Garage doors must be architectural, carriage -style doors that complement the main
building and garage building.
The carriage door with cross bracing is an acceptable style but the specific material was not
provided.
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
(a). Pursuant to Section 8.0 of Schedule "S" of the City's LDRs, the BPB has
reviewed the proposed Certificate of Appropriateness and all application documentation and
matters relating thereto in accordance with the procedures for altering historic landmarks or
structures within historic districts as set forth in Schedule "S."
(b). Specifically, Schedule "S" and Schedule 'W" of the City's LDRs provide as
follows:
(1). New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction shall not
destroy historic materials that characterize the property.
(2). New work shall be differentiated from the old and shall be compatible
with the massing, size, scale, and architectural features to protect the architectural
integrity of the property and its environment.
(3). New additions and adjacent or related new construction shall be
undertaken in such a manner that if removed in the fixture, the essential form and integrity
Signate regulations were recently consolidated into Schedule "K71 of the City's LDRs.
31Pagc
Ud! rMIA muk wd inn Him bus rnwhw dy"ON up! IWOUP lJOK 1100YOUS "rz •OR 51C w"ab
151W,
nnowwK pays,", W, ion
not Own ZATM WOO %ny"631
XG ME!
Mom a! hic" i fa.�,i
7W 108MAUJI19n)
gnhwl lul waLljow; 5w 'iii!a
W, MWIR "i - 1, !')r. XI; fl;rilivi
%a 00'UYlq !"A" ofilljorl"'? t1w, *'�" "'di
w0h.",
;..)fl !11;42 wun 1001 W) 'G;*i:i;'— .(l;
MsTnoy 5d HM bun A iif f€11) -it 000,71wh K llwic. i r)
M, Ann ;a, qw am at dkv
HM"Mu"Un at "Mi Ynor"q WAIS gh'sk
5d Hgoh ban wuhlby OWN AQ
Qpw Lt. inik h4way; at .-urdl 01 A jl;:'! c -,.i
MIA 114) SMIn 1A" Ahose 00 'art'!
of the historic property and its environment would be unimpaired.
(4). For new construction, additions and alterations, the use of the wall finishes
most acceptable for the architectural style is required.
(5). New materials shall be installed so as not to conceal or damage historical
architectural elements.
(c). To the extent that a conclusion of law as set forth herein also constitutes a factual
finding, then such shall be taken to be so as part of this Development Order.
(d). The proposed Certificate of Appropriateness is hereby found and determined to
comply with the aforestated
(e). Additionally, the proposed changes are consistent with the purpose and intent of
Schedule S and complies with the design guidelines in Schedule S.
(f). This is a Development Order and shall not create contractual rights of the property
owner against the City nor contractual obligations of the City to the property owner and, to that
end, the property owner shall have no contractual rights or remedies against the City with regard
to any land use action of the City.
(g). The City has not waived any rights or remedies by taken the action set forth herein
or any successive development orders and reserves any and all rights and remedies available to
the City under controlling law including, but not limited to, the protections under the laws
pertaining to sovereign immunity.
ORDER
NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS ORDERED THAT:
(1). The aforementioned application for a Certificate of Appropriateness is
APPROVED subject to the following conditions;
(a). The design of the garage must be in character with the surrounding area;
and
(b) Details for garage doors must be submitted to City Planning Staff for
approval as meeting Schedule S standards; and
41Pagc
%lyi `,, `N':;1: 't 0 i j". I
10 WM2 G. on :% -0 6whowu Ud Hok Annom WN (a)
Mundl it awvdmao; "!twof findl in, in 'flail if} !"Imh 3jV'1jY:;, 411.." (j'i" A
MW j"uatqnjmG eid; it) ymp ho or in r i rinAw ad WdR dow MY Inibb
', j(1*if-Lr brin .) ..rqjjlo x1i fiiiw Lis xWom—L, a,,jj .ill}
'0-mwp-lqt !fl.`Jo eldah Mumma 4VA3 ho Had? bna M0 113"yowc! 1; 1, lid f Xp
,mrlj -;A !'fit; -i:;n.vo jr1onq at Q 10 ad; it, wobujikic: Wrommon wo YIN OAT 10. LIZ 111"100
q0? CEO nVont, alu "wil ps 0:
MY KN a icy hohou vdinvis; Id Winum w aQviG L -vii:%-i Ion inifii 4,C)
t;fv;
Ras! :61 13% aloyhowaiq Dal ail nolow! wo m
mi Xkjpw1wmqwqqA 10 mrsphy! n VA MAWARM" LAmb"SnoW W A 1 1
b m;
Vi VAQ "; boldff}!ilii' d taunt m;4;"' d
(c). Any dispute between City Planning Staff and the
I
lill!lllllliii llill;Illillfillill lillilillill 11111111, ll�jil
I ; I -309rWw r, .w.��
I ii i I! I I I iiii, i !I ill ii I i ill I ill ill I I I w 1
accordance with the controlling provisions of law.
Done and Ordered on the date first written below.,
As approved and authorized for execution by the Historic Preservation Board of the City of
Sanford at its meeting of July 27, 2022.
Traci Houchin, MMC, FCRM, City Clerk
HISTORIC PRESER"TATIO3 BOARD
�S-MQFN (�WN LE�
Date: q
Nune,pro tune to J;ly 27,2022 CIA R1 QM PM
r r:lIqngl'i rl�glg�lIl i;i a�al; I , 1112
I
i� I il I Ili 11 11 111 1
ilililillill'!IlliiiI Ill I iiiiiijilIIillillilli 11 "IR11111 !j 1111 ill ll�1111�11 I I
Development Order, the undersigned narned persons having full authority to execute this
5
Printed Name )Wf
1 4- MA.4-&
10.1
Oliver Bond
:les is land
5 111
.7j
14-
vj'
IT i
�A a0 V, it 'A K" 0
ACC Z
.1 T 14 ,
vvi bru; a wf�) I ff(; 4"! JAP 11,
d" r:, ii;, Ouf; 1vb 'Al"
01
!)!Jfm,!:,��
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF SEMINOLE)
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me by means of 2Lphysical presence
or O online notarization, this &-236 day of .02e,&.. 2022 by Oliver Bond and Jessica Bond. They
are personally known to me or produced F1 -,j % L as identification,
919i
tate of FWWa
nt Shut
GQ 319656
023
TARY PUBLIC
My commission expires:
61Page
�A =c5mle =;i4q
'fitiMoua Jim?,
no D w
Ye.
t